Edwidge Danticat on Haitian Art and Literature (Ep. 108)
Hello, everyone.
大家好。
Welcome again to Conversations with Tyler.
欢迎再次来到《与泰勒对话》。
Today, I am very pleased to be chatting with Edwidge Danticat, the famed Haitian American author, also winner of a MacArthur Genius Fellowship.
今天,我很高兴能与美国海地著名作家、麦克阿瑟天才奖获得者埃德维奇·丹蒂卡特(Edwidge Danticat)交谈。
Edwidge, thank you for coming on the show.
艾德维奇,感谢您参加节目。
Thank you so much for having me.
非常感谢你邀请我。
I have so many questions.
我有很多问题。
Let’s start with one about you.
让我们从关于您的一个开始。
Now, you moved to the United States from Haiti, I believe, when you were 12.
现在,我相信,当你 12 岁时,你就从海地搬到了美国。
How is it you have learned so much about Haitian history in the meantime, since you didn’t do most of your schooling in Haiti?
既然你的大部分学业不是在海地完成的,那么你是如何同时了解海地历史的呢?
I often say, and my parents used to say as well, that I left Haiti, but Haiti didn’t leave me.
我经常说,我的父母也常说,我离开了海地,但海地并没有离开我。
Twelve is, I think, young enough to transition somewhat easily, but also to have formed so many memories.
我认为十二岁足够年轻,可以轻松地过渡,但也形成了如此多的记忆。
I had, actually, a big chunk of primary education in Haiti.
事实上,我在海地接受了很大一部分初等教育。
Having learned both oral history and written history, I brought a lot of that with me to the US, enough that I was curious when I got here to find out more from this side of things.
在学习了口述历史和书面历史之后,我把很多东西带到了美国,这足以让我在到达这里时很好奇,想从这方面了解更多。
I think it was, in part, a love for Haiti that continued and also a curiosity about history in general, but Haitian history in particular.
我认为这在一定程度上是对海地持续的热爱,也是对整个历史(尤其是海地历史)的好奇心。
There’s a shift, I think, in Haitian cultural history.
我认为海地文化历史发生了转变。
If you think of the 1960s or ’70s, Haitian cultural history is centered in Haiti.
如果你回想 20 世纪 60 年代或 70 年代,海地文化历史的中心就是海地。
You have Mick Jagger, Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis — they go to Port-au-Prince, Pétion-Ville.
你有米克·贾格尔、杰奎琳·肯尼迪·奥纳西斯——他们去了太子港、佩蒂翁维尔。
They buy paintings.
他们买画。
They bring them back.
他们把它们带回来。
Everything is very Haitian-centered, and that seems to end in the 1980s.
一切都非常以海地为中心,这似乎在 20 世纪 80 年代就结束了。
Why did that happen?
为什么会发生这种事?
Yes, there was a time, even in the ’50s, where you had cruise ships going to Haiti, which I’ve always found somewhat interesting because all that time that you had the tourism, that high level of tourism, was still during the dictatorship.
是的,曾经有一段时间,即使是在 50 年代,也有游轮前往海地,我一直觉得这有点有趣,因为一直以来,旅游业的高水平,仍然是在独裁统治时期。
And so people were going at that time, anyway — the folks you mentioned and others.
无论如何,当时人们都在去——你提到的人和其他人。
Then, in the 1980s, during the pandemic of AIDS, Haiti was designated by the CDC as a .
然后,在 20 世纪 80 年代,艾滋病流行期间,海地被疾病预防控制中心指定为艾滋病毒疫区。
.
。
.
。
Haitians were labeled a high-risk group for AIDS, and we were the only ones designated by nationality.
海地人被列为艾滋病高危人群,而我们是唯一按国籍指定的人群。
It was Haitians, hemophiliacs, heroin addicts, and homosexuals.
他们是海地人、血友病患者、海洛因成瘾者和同性恋者。
That came out of some cases of people who had contracted AIDS and who came to a hospital here in Miami and were reported to the CDC.
这是来自一些感染艾滋病的人的病例,这些人来到迈阿密的一家医院,并向疾病预防控制中心报告。
Really, that designation killed the tourism industry in Haiti.
确实,这个称号扼杀了海地的旅游业。
It was later, after much demonstrations, after a lot of research, it was corrected.
后来经过多次论证、大量研究后,才改正。
But it really killed whatever tourism industry there was in Haiti, which was already a strange kind of tourism anyway because people felt happy to go at a time of very strict dictatorship.
但这确实扼杀了海地的旅游业,无论如何,这已经是一种奇怪的旅游业,因为人们在非常严格的独裁统治时期很乐意去那里。
There was already something a little strange about that, but whatever tourism industry there was, was destroyed by the AIDS epidemic.
这已经有点奇怪了,但无论旅游业如何,都被艾滋病的流行摧毁了。
If you think of Haitian culture today, is it correct to think that the Haitian diaspora is now Haitian culture?
如果你想到今天的海地文化,认为海地侨民现在就是海地文化是否正确?
If you think of Haitian painting, there’s Duval-Carrié, but he’s lived in Puerto Rico and France and Florida.
如果你想到海地绘画,那就是杜瓦尔-卡里,但他住在波多黎各、法国和佛罗里达。
You are the leading Haitian writer, if one were going to call you that.
如果有人这样称呼你的话,你就是海地的顶尖作家。
Wyclef Jean — from Haiti, but now mostly in North America.
Wyclef Jean——来自海地,但现在主要在北美。
Leyla McCalla.
莱拉·麦卡拉。
Some would even call Basquiat a Haitian artist.
有些人甚至称巴斯奎特为海地艺术家。
Is that now outside of Haiti, what Haitian culture is?
现在在海地之外,海地文化是什么?
No, I think that would be incorrect to say because there is still a great vibrant culture inside Haiti.
不,我认为这种说法是不正确的,因为海地境内仍然存在着伟大而充满活力的文化。
There are wonderful writers inside Haiti, as well.
海地国内也有出色的作家。
There’re wonderful visual artists, musicians.
这里有出色的视觉艺术家和音乐家。
If you think of it like any other diaspora, we’re going to be like .
如果您像其他侨民一样看待它,那么我们就会像这样。
.
。
.
。
If you’re in North America or if you’re out in Europe, there are some mechanisms that make our work more visible.
如果您在北美或欧洲,有一些机制可以让我们的工作更加引人注目。
My work is in English, so naturally, people have more access to it more easily.
我的作品是英文的,所以自然地,人们可以更轻松地访问它。
But there’s a really strong and vibrant culture inside Haiti as well that people like us — we feel fed by, that we feel is still important to us as readers.
但海地国内也有一种非常强大和充满活力的文化,像我们这样的人 ——我们感到被这种文化所滋养,我们觉得这种文化对我们作为读者来说仍然很重要。
I’m a writer, but I’m also a reader.
我是一名作家,但我也是一名读者。
I appreciate art.
我欣赏艺术。
I’m on the council of Centre d’Art d’Haiti, an esteemed institution that goes back several decades now, so there’s still that culture.
我是海地艺术中心的理事会成员,这是一个受人尊敬的机构,其历史可以追溯到几十年前,所以这种文化仍然存在。
It’s really a powerful statement, I think, to Haitians and Haitian culture because there’s so many obstacles all the time in the way of artists in Haiti, but they still are thriving and are very .
我认为,对于海地人和海地文化来说,这确实是一个强有力的声明,因为海地艺术家的道路上一直存在很多障碍,但他们仍然在蓬勃发展,而且非常繁荣。
.
。
.
。
been wonderful expressing what’s happening very powerfully through their work.
通过他们的作品非常有力地表达了正在发生的事情。
Do you think the Haitian diaspora is culturally stable?
您认为海地侨民文化稳定吗?
Or do you think it will, in essence, be absorbed and assimilated into a more narrowly Afro-American culture?
或者你认为它本质上会被吸收和同化为更狭隘的非裔美国文化吗?
I think because there’s often so much happening in Haiti, let’s say, that tie — what we would call the umbilical cord — is really married to Haiti.
我认为,因为海地经常发生很多事情,所以可以说,这条领带——我们称之为脐带——确实与海地结下了不解之缘。
Even over several generations, the Haitians who I know — I don’t want to speak for everybody — remain very connected to Haiti, and want their children to know Haiti, and want that connection through language, through food, through music.
即使经过几代人的时间,我所认识的海地人 ——“我不想代表所有人”——仍然与海地有着密切的联系,并希望他们的孩子了解海地,并希望通过语言、食物和音乐建立这种联系。
No diaspora is fully stable.
没有哪个侨民是完全稳定的。
Of course, there’s integration, there’s assimilation.
当然,有整合,有同化。
That happens with every immigrant community over the generations, certainly, for sure, but there’s a certain tie to Haiti that the diaspora has.
当然,每一代移民社区都会发生这种情况,但侨民与海地有着一定的联系。
There’re so many diaspora organizations, neighborhood organizations, where people support schools in the neighborhoods where they come from, where they support organizations.
有很多侨民组织、社区组织,人们支持他们来自的社区的学校,他们支持这些组织。
Part of it, I think, that tie, that connection is connected to the fact that Haiti is often in crisis, and people in the diaspora are often the first-line responders after people in Haiti.
我认为,这种联系的一部分与海地经常陷入危机这一事实有关,而海外侨民往往是继海地人民之后的第一线响应者。
After Haitians in Haiti are Haitians in diaspora.
继在海地的海地人之后,便是散居国外的海地人。
Even within our families, if there’s an illness, and that sometimes extends to the larger community.
即使在我们的家庭内部,如果出现疾病,有时也会蔓延到更大的社区。
Definitely, there’s integration, but we have a diaspora that goes back further than people know, yet that connection to Haiti throughout the generations has been made.
当然,融合是存在的,但我们的侨民的历史比人们所知的还要久远,但与海地的联系已经代代相传。
Then, with these artists that you mentioned — Leyla McCalla — she’s a wonderful artist, born of Haitian parents, yet her music reflects that.
然后,对于你提到的这些艺术家——“Leyla McCalla”——她是一位出色的艺术家,出生于海地父母,但她的音乐反映了这一点。
Artists like Mélissa Laveaux.
梅丽莎·拉沃 (Mélissa Laveaux) 等艺术家。
You mentioned Basquiat.
你提到了巴斯奎特。
I think that’s also a testament to a thread that runs through Haiti and the diaspora.
我认为这也证明了贯穿海地和海外侨民的一条线索。
Do you think there is, in fact, a natural language for Haitian literature?
您认为海地文学实际上有一种自然语言吗?
If you think of the earlier Haitian classics that you’ve had a hand in translating — they were written in French.
如果你想想你参与翻译的早期海地经典著作——它们是用法语写的。
Your work, of course, is written in English.
当然,你的作品是用英语写的。
It’s been slow to have been translated into Creole.
它被翻译成克里奥尔语的速度很慢。
Is it a fundamental fact about the future of Haitian literature that there’s not a natural language there?
那里没有自然语言是关于海地文学未来的基本事实吗?
It’s such a topic of discussion often among critics of Haitian literature — what language is Haitian literature written in?
这是海地文学批评家经常讨论的话题——“海地文学是用什么语言写成的?”
I think now, some people — I can’t speak for everyone — but I think most people who study Haitian literature will say that it’s now a multilingual literature.
我想现在,有些人 ——“我不能代表所有人”—— 但我认为大多数研究海地文学的人会说它现在是一种多语言文学。
There’s literature in Creole, certainly, which is probably closer to the primary language that most Haitians speak Creole.
当然,有克里奥尔语的文学作品,这可能更接近大多数海地人说克里奥尔语的主要语言。
That was slow to come.
那是来得很慢的。
There was always literature in Creole, but not as much as there is now.
克里奥尔语文学一直都有,但不像现在那么多。
Haitian literature is mostly written in French, and like you said, we’ve worked on translating.
海地文学大部分是用法语写的,就像你说的,我们一直致力于翻译。
I’ve worked with others in translating, for example, a masterpiece of Haitian literature called L’espace d’un cillement by Jacques Stephen Alexis, which we translated with Carrol Coates as In the Flicker of an Eyelid.
例如,我与其他人合作翻译了雅克·斯蒂芬·亚历克西斯(Jacques Stephen Alexis)的海地文学杰作《L’espace d’un cillement》,我们与卡罗尔·科茨(Carrol Coates)一起翻译了《眼睑的闪烁》(In the Flicker of an Eyelid)。
I edited these two books, Haiti Noir and Haiti Noir 2, in which we translated many contemporary Haitian writers.
我编辑了这两本书,《海地黑色》和《海地黑色2》,其中我们翻译了许多当代海地作家。
Then we have writers now who are Haitian American or Haitian Canadian, like Roxane Gay and Myriam Chancy, who write directly in English.
现在,我们有海地裔美国人或海地裔加拿大人,比如罗克珊·盖伊 (Roxane Gay) 和米里亚姆·昌西 (Myriam Chancy),他们直接用英语写作。
So it’s a multi-language literature through immigration and migration.
所以这是一部通过移民和迁徙而产生的多语言文学。
We have writers who are writing in Chile and in the Dominican Republic in Spanish, and that’s another growing layer of Haitian literature abroad — this Haitian literature that’s so far mostly produced a lot of poetry in Spanish.
我们有作家在智利和多米尼加共和国用西班牙语写作,这是海地文学在国外不断增长的另一层 ——到目前为止,海地文学主要创作了大量西班牙语诗歌。
There was a novel before by a Haitian writer named Micheline Dusseck, who had written one of the first novels about Haiti in Spanish.
以前有一位海地作家米什琳·杜塞克写过一部小说,她是最早用西班牙语写的关于海地的小说之一。
It’s a linguistically interesting literature and to see all the tentacles of it, if you will.
这是一部语言学上很有趣的文学作品,如果你愿意的话,可以看看它的所有触角。
What do you think of the .
您对此有何看法?
.
。
.
。
you might call them outsider novels about Haiti?
你可能会称它们为关于海地的局外人小说?
There’s Graham Greene; there’s Victor Hugo’s Bug-Jargal, which is about the Haitian Revolution.
还有格雷厄姆·格林;维克多·雨果的《Bug-Jargal》是关于海地革命的。
Are those cultural appropriation?
这些是文化挪用吗?
Are they bad novels?
它们是烂小说吗?
How do they strike you?
他们如何打击你?
Some are good, some are bad.
有些是好的,有些是坏的。
There’re some wonderful ones like Madison Smartt Bell’s trilogy, All Souls’ Rising, on the Haitian Revolution.
其中有一些精彩的作品,例如麦迪逊·斯玛特·贝尔关于海地革命的三部曲《万灵崛起》。
I think that those were wonderful.
我认为那些都很棒。
There’re some really great ones; there’re some that are a little cringey.
其中有一些确实很棒;有些有点尴尬。
But I wouldn’t say to anybody that you can’t write about it.
但我不会对任何人说你不能写它。
I think writers should be able to write whatever they want.
我认为作家应该能够写任何他们想写的东西。
You should expect people to respond.
你应该期待人们的回应。
If you do it with nuance and care, that’s really important.
如果你细致入微、小心翼翼地做到这一点,那真的很重要。
There are some tropes that often sometimes people just fall into when they’re writing about Haiti.
人们在写海地时常常会陷入一些比喻。
The zombie situation.
僵尸的情况。
Sometimes they approach it like it’s never been done before.
有时他们对待它就像以前从未做过一样。
If you do it with care, if you do it with nuance, I’m open to reading it.
如果你小心翼翼,如果你细致入微,我愿意阅读它。
Why does Haiti have the very best food in the Caribbean?
为什么海地拥有加勒比地区最好的食物?
Well, because we just do.
嗯,因为我们就是这么做的。
I’m perhaps biased.
我也许有偏见。
I just have to say, overall in the Caribbean, we have amazing food.
我只想说,总的来说,在加勒比地区,我们有很棒的食物。
There’s wonderful food throughout the Caribbean.
整个加勒比地区都有美味的食物。
But Haitian food, in particular, I love because we have great spices, and even if the food is a little fad in some cases .
但我特别喜欢海地食物,因为我们有很棒的香料,即使这些食物在某些情况下有点时尚。
.
。
.
。
you have the pikliz, which is sort of a pickled cabbage, carrots, like a spice that you sprinkle on top.
你有pikliz,这是一种腌制的卷心菜、胡萝卜,就像撒在上面的香料一样。
For people who like meat, there’s griot, which is pork; tassot, goat.
对于喜欢吃肉的人来说,有griot,即猪肉;对于喜欢吃肉的人来说,有griot,即猪肉;塔索,山羊。
There’s stuff that, even if you’re vegan, you can like, like mais moulin, which is cornmeal.
有些东西,即使你是素食主义者,你也会喜欢的,比如 mais moulin,即玉米粉。
Sos pwa — I think it’s a very rich and wonderful cuisine, but I am biased.
Sos pwa — 我认为这是一道非常丰富和美妙的菜肴,但我有偏见。
People who have not had Haitian food, if you know anybody who’s Haitian, on January 1st, go over to their house — when we can go over to people’s houses again — go for soup joumou, which is a squash soup that we drink on the first of January to celebrate Haitian independence.
没有吃过海地食物的人,如果你认识任何海地人,1 月 1 日,去他们家 ——“当我们可以再次去人们家时”—— 去喝汤 joumou,这是我们在一月 1 日喝的一种南瓜汤,以庆祝海地独立。
Why is Haitian black mushroom rice so good?
海天黑菇饭为什么这么好吃?
It’s the mushroom.
这是蘑菇。
That’s the key.
这是关键。
Actually, I live in Miami, and that gives me a little more access to the djon-djon, so I’ve had to ship it to friends throughout the States.
事实上,我住在迈阿密,这让我有更多机会接触 djon-djon,所以我不得不将它运送给全美各地的朋友。
There’s a key to it in terms of just how you wash the mushroom and just the right .
关键在于如何清洗蘑菇以及正确的清洗方式。
.
。
.
。
They try to make a kind of cube thing, but the cube thing is just not the same as the actual mushroom that you boil and you squeeze.
他们试图制作一种立方体的东西,但立方体的东西与你煮和挤压的实际蘑菇不同。
Some people — if you’re from the north, like my friends from the north — will put some cashews in that.
有些人 —— 如果你来自北方,就像我来自北方的朋友 —— 会在里面放一些腰果。
That’s another level, with some cashews.
那是另一个层次,还有一些腰果。
The collective buses in Haiti, the tap-taps, of course — why are they so beautifully painted?
海地的集体巴士,当然是水龙头——为什么它们涂得这么漂亮?
Why does that make economic sense?
为什么这具有经济意义?
Well, I’ve gone to Haiti with a lot of foreigners, at some point.
嗯,在某个时候,我和很多外国人一起去过海地。
Like me.
像我这样的。
There’s a time when I used to go — we had a program for college students every summer, and I used to love when they land to see the tap-tap.
曾经有一段时间,我曾经去——我们每年夏天都会为大学生举办一个项目,我曾经很喜欢他们登陆时看到水龙头。
It’s so striking because it just feels like, “Oh, I’m in this world full of art.” They seem, to me, moving canvases.
它是如此引人注目,因为它感觉就像,“哦,我在这个充满艺术的世界里。”对我来说,它们就像是移动的画布。
What I love, personally, most about tap-tap, even after you get used to the visual feast that they are, I love the sayings on them.
就我个人而言,我最喜欢的就是 Tap-Tap,即使你已经习惯了它们带来的视觉盛宴,我也喜欢它们上面的谚语。
You would see like, of course, basketball stars from here.
当然,从这里你会看到篮球明星。
At some point, not too long ago, Toni Morrison, after she died, was on a tap-tap.
就在不久前的某个时刻,托妮·莫里森去世后,她的生活陷入了困境。
It’s just that people really soak up what’s happening around.
只是人们真正吸收了周围发生的事情。
But the sayings are also great.
但俗话说得也很棒。
One of my favorite sayings on the tap-tap was “w ap pale, m ap travay,” like, “You’re talking and I’m working.” I felt it was so powerful in terms of how you respond to people who talk badly about you.
我在 Tap-Tap 上最喜欢的一句话是“w ap pape, m ap travay”,比如“你在说话,我在工作。”我觉得它对于你如何回应那些说你坏话的人来说是如此强大。
“w ap pale, m ap travay.
“w ap 苍白,m ap travay。
You’re talking, I’m working.” Things like that.
你在说话,我在工作。”诸如此类的事情。
Also, the tap-taps with the art sometimes will have messages of gratitude.
此外,带有艺术的敲击声有时会带有感激的信息。
A tap-tap might have a message of gratitude to the driver’s mother or to whoever contributed.
敲击声可能会传达对司机母亲或任何做出贡献的人的感激之情。
A lot of them are to Jesus, to God, to the Virgin and other religious figures, but also to people in the person’s life who contributed to the business.
其中很多是献给耶稣、上帝、圣母玛利亚和其他宗教人物,也献给生命中为企业做出贡献的人。
I always find them very beautiful to look at, but also really wonderful moving pieces of art.
我总是觉得它们看起来非常漂亮,而且也是非常美妙动人的艺术品。
If I think of the Haitian arts today, I think of painting possibly as having peaked between the ’40s and the ’70s.
如果我今天想到海地艺术,我会想到绘画可能在 40 年代和 70 年代之间达到顶峰。
The most interesting work today tends to be in Vodou sculpture.
当今最有趣的作品往往是伏都雕塑。
Why has that shift come about?
为什么会发生这种转变?
Those are very large pieces.
这些都是非常大的碎片。
They’re like installations.
它们就像装置。
They are hard to buy.
它们很难买到。
They’re hard to transport.
它们很难运输。
I think if you stayed there, you would be reducing your possible level of enjoyment because what’s most in that early period, the Centre d’Art period in the ’40s, like the early period, when the tourism that you were talking about, when people went to Haiti, what they bought the most was what they call naif, primitif art, which is super colorful, really beautiful figures, often market scenes.
我想如果你呆在那里,你可能会降低你的享受水平,因为在早期,40年代的艺术中心时期,就像早期,当你谈论的旅游业,当人们去海地时,他们买的最多的是他们所谓的naif,primitif艺术,这是超级丰富多彩的,非常美丽的人物,通常是市场场景。
That’s traveled very well.
这走得很好。
But there was always, at that same time, artists who were a little bit more adventurous, artists who were somewhat abstract.
但与此同时,总有一些更具冒险精神、有些抽象的艺术家。
At the same time, there were these artists who were like, “This is what the tourists want.
与此同时,也有一些艺术家说:“这就是游客想要的。
That’s what I’m going to produce.” Throughout the Caribbean, even if you went to other islands, you would see these paintings, and they became almost a little bit mass-produced, but they’re gorgeous.
这就是我要制作的东西。”在整个加勒比地区,即使你去其他岛屿,你也会看到这些画,它们几乎有点批量生产,但它们很华丽。
I have some.
我有一些。
The sculptures you’re talking about — those were started actually by .
你所说的雕塑 ——那些实际上是由……开始的。
.
。
.
。
I used to work for Jonathan Demme, the filmmaker, who was a huge collector of Haitian art.
我曾经为电影制片人乔纳森·戴米工作,他是海地艺术品的巨大收藏家。
In the office, whenever we acquired those sculptures .
在办公室里,每当我们购买这些雕塑时。
.
。
.
。
I traveled a lot to Haiti with him.
我和他一起去了很多海地。
He called them Liautauds because the original artist was Liautaud.
他称它们为Liautauds,因为最初的艺术家是Liautaud。
When I was growing up, in cemeteries, often we had metal flowers, really, because you would do a wreath of metal.
当我长大的时候,在墓地里,我们经常有金属花,真的,因为你会做一个金属花环。
It would be metal from oil drums because that lasted longer, as opposed to if you have a wreath of just roses — that dies quickly, so people would make these beautiful wreaths.
它会是油桶中的金属,因为它持续时间更长,而不是如果你有一个只有玫瑰的花环——它很快就会死去,所以人们会制作这些美丽的花环。
Liautaud was from St. Mark, which is really the home of these sculptures.
利奥托来自圣马可,那里确实是这些雕塑的故乡。
Now, there’s a whole industry in those sculptures for sure.
现在,这些雕塑肯定已经成为一个完整的行业。
I have to say, they’re very hard, I agree.
我不得不说,他们很难,我同意。
You can’t just put that in your suitcase, often, like you would the paintings.
通常,你不能像对待画作那样将其放入手提箱中。
People used to roll them.
人们过去常常滚动它们。
But they’re gorgeous, and now they’re almost three dimensional.
但它们很华丽,现在它们几乎是三维的。
One Christmas, we bought one that was a nativity scene that was 3D.
有一年圣诞节,我们买了一个 3D 耶稣诞生场景。
But there are a lot of wonderful young artists now.
但现在有很多优秀的年轻艺术家。
Some of them are moving away from the more primitive, naive Lionel St-Eloi.
他们中的一些人正在远离更原始、天真的莱昂内尔·圣埃洛伊。
There’re so many whose names are escaping me, but there are just wonderful artists worth exploring.
有很多人的名字我都记不清了,但总有一些出色的艺术家值得探索。
You mentioned Duval-Carrié, who is outside of Haiti, but there are quite a few other young artists, too, who are inside Haiti, who would use both that style of sculpture but also do painting, who do installations or doing really, really exciting things.
你提到了海地境外的杜瓦尔-卡里埃,但海地境内也有不少其他年轻艺术家,他们既会使用这种雕塑风格,也会进行绘画,他们会做装置或做一些非常非常令人兴奋的事情。
I own a Zobop by Liautaud, by the way.
顺便说一下,我有一把 Liautaud 的 Zobop。
Great work.
很棒的工作。
It’s by the fireplace.
就在壁炉旁。
Why is it you think that Black African Americans have not evolved as natural collectors of Haitian art?
您认为为什么非裔美国人没有发展成为海地艺术的天然收藏家?
It seems to be much more the nerdy White guys who buy it, or well-to-do families.
购买它的似乎更多是书呆子白人,或者富裕家庭。
I know a lot of African Americans who collect Haitian art, starting with, for example, Ishmael Reed, whose wife had a gallery.
我认识很多收藏海地艺术品的非裔美国人,例如以实玛利·里德(Ishmael Reed),他的妻子拥有一家画廊。
People like Danny Glover.
像丹尼·格洛弗这样的人。
Even friends that, again, when we traveled with folks to Haiti — a lot of them were African American, and there are quite a few African American collectors.
甚至朋友们也说,当我们和人们一起去海地旅行时,他们中的很多人都是非裔美国人,而且还有不少非裔美国收藏家。
My friend Carine Fabius has a gallery in LA called Galerie Lakaye.
我的朋友 Carine Fabius 在洛杉矶有一家名为 Galerie Lakaye 的画廊。
It’s a wonderful gallery because it’s in their home.
这是一个很棒的画廊,因为它就在他们的家里。
Her husband, Pascal, is an artist who’s worked with the artists in Grand Rue, who do actually really amazing urban sculptures with discarded dolls, computer boards, and sometimes skulls.
她的丈夫帕斯卡是一位艺术家,曾与格兰德街的艺术家合作,他们用废弃的娃娃、电脑板,有时甚至是头骨,创作了非常令人惊叹的城市雕塑。
They recently had a show here at Moca.
他们最近在 Moca 举办了一场演出。
Carine, for example, I think, has worked with a lot of African American collectors, including some in Hollywood, but some outside, also ordinary people who collect.
例如,我认为卡琳(Carine)曾与许多非裔美国收藏家合作过,其中包括好莱坞的一些收藏家,但也有一些外面的收藏家,也有普通收藏家。
There’s been, also, this marriage of African American art, in some cases, with Haitian art, like Lois Mailou Jones, who went to Haiti, who has spent time there, and this connection there with some African American artists who are very aware of Haitian art as well.
在某些情况下,非裔美国艺术与海地艺术也存在着这种联姻,比如洛伊丝·麦卢·琼斯(Lois Mailou Jones),他去了海地,在那里度过了一段时光,并与一些也非常了解海地艺术的非裔美国艺术家建立了这种联系。
How much Vodou inspiration is there in your writing?
您的写作中有多少伏都教灵感?
Well, it’s part of Haitian culture.
嗯,这是海地文化的一部分。
One of the things that when you were asking about the outside gaze in Haitian literature, I think sometimes it’s easy to fall into that trap of, like, “Oh, let me throw in some Vodou just to exotify things.”
其中一件事是,当你问起海地文学中的外界目光时,我认为有时很容易陷入这样的陷阱,比如,“哦,让我加入一些伏都教只是为了让事物变得异国情调。”
In my work, I treat that as a worldview.
在我的工作中,我将其视为一种世界观。
Some people might be practitioners; some people might not be.
有的人可能是修炼者;有的人可能是修炼者。有些人可能不是。
I also like to show a whole range of religious practices in my characters because not everybody is monolithic.
我也喜欢在我的角色中展示一系列的宗教活动,因为并不是每个人都是单一的。
As they’re not in their behavior, they’re not monolithic in their religious practice as well, so I try to show it as a whole range of religious practices.
由于他们的行为不一样,他们的宗教实践也不是单一的,所以我试图将其展示为一个完整的宗教实践范围。
In Breath, Eyes, Memory, for example, the family certainly have their family loa.
例如,在《呼吸、眼睛、记忆》中,这个家庭当然有他们的家族神灵。
They have their own practice, but there are members of the family that also practice other religions.
他们有自己的宗教信仰,但也有一些家庭成员信仰其他宗教。
To show the whole range of religious practices that there would be in a family like that, some of them are also Protestant, and sometimes that actually leads to some conflicts within some families.
为了显示这样的家庭中会有各种各样的宗教活动,其中一些人也是新教徒,有时这实际上会导致一些家庭内部的一些冲突。
I like to show all the nuance of all that.
我喜欢展示所有这些的细微差别。
Your novel about the twins, Untwine — isn’t that just a Vodou novel?
你写的关于双胞胎的小说《Untwine》——这不就是一部伏都小说吗?
And I mean that as praise.
我的意思是赞美。
I didn’t think of it that way.
我不这么认为。
There’s certainly twin loas in Vodou, and these girls are twins.
伏都确实有双胞胎洛阿,而这些女孩是双胞胎。
I’d always been fascinated by twins.
我一直对双胞胎着迷。
I think maybe that could be one interpretation.
我想也许这可能是一种解释。
That wasn’t how I started out, but I think that could be one interpretation.
这不是我开始的方式,但我认为这可能是一种解释。
To me, I just think Marassa when I’m reading it, right?
对我来说,当我读到它时,我只想到马拉萨,对吗?
The whole myth of the twins and rivalry and beginning, the end, struggle.
双胞胎的整个神话、竞争、开始、结束、斗争。
Yes.
是的。
Is it because they’re Marassa?
是因为他们是马拉萨吗?
Because there are a lot of novels about twins as well, but they’re written by people who are not from Haiti.
因为也有很多关于双胞胎的小说,但它们都是由非海地人写的。
Like I said, I don’t object to that as an interpretation, but I don’t think that’s the only thing that it is.
就像我说的,我不反对这种解释,但我不认为这是唯一的事情。
It’s also about sisterhood and illness and separation and so forth.
它还涉及姐妹情谊、疾病和分离等等。
But again, I’m fine with that interpretation.
但同样,我同意这种解释。
In a world with so much mobile and social media, do you think radio is still of central importance for Haitian politics, as it had been in the past?
在移动和社交媒体如此之多的世界中,您认为广播仍然像过去一样对海地政治至关重要吗?
I think radio remains very important there.
我认为广播在那里仍然非常重要。
For example, there are a lot of cultural figures, even younger people, in Haiti who emerged out of radio culture and now have transitioned into more social media, who do Lives and Facebook but who started out in radio.
例如,海地有很多文化人物,甚至是年轻人,他们从广播文化中脱颖而出,现在已经转向更多的社交媒体,他们做直播和 Facebook,但最初是从广播开始的。
Radio certainly was very important when I was growing up, and there weren’t as many other outlets.
在我的成长过程中,广播当然非常重要,而且没有那么多其他渠道。
Now I find, for example, my mother-in-law, who’s 85, who lives with us — she’s in Haiti most of the time.
例如,现在我发现我的婆婆,她 85 岁了,和我们住在一起 ——她大部分时间都在海地。
Sometimes she’ll watch a YouTube video about something that’s happening in Haiti, but it’s a YouTube video of someone in a radio station, and she can watch it on YouTube.
有时她会观看有关海地发生的事情的 YouTube 视频,但这是广播电台某人的 YouTube 视频,她可以在 YouTube 上观看。
Someone can send the clip on WhatsApp.
有人可以通过 WhatsApp 发送该剪辑。
I think radio now is part of a series of many different ways that people get information.
我认为广播现在是人们获取信息的一系列不同方式的一部分。
When we’re in the country, if you don’t have internet, it remains one way that you get news, on the radio.
当我们在乡下时,如果你没有互联网,通过广播仍然是你获取新闻的一种方式。
Also, I find, even the older people in my life get a lot of news through their phones, through WhatsApp, also through YouTube clips.
此外,我发现,即使是我生活中的老年人也通过手机、WhatsApp 和 YouTube 剪辑获取很多新闻。
There’s a constant loop of information now that radio is just one part of, whereas for example, when I was younger, it was the primary, if not the only source of information that we had.
现在信息不断循环,广播只是其中的一部分,而例如,当我年轻的时候,它是我们拥有的主要信息来源,即使不是唯一的信息来源。
With a Haitian background, do you think you have a different perspective on the fake news debates of the United States?
您有海地背景,您认为您对美国的假新闻争论有不同的看法吗?
Because Haiti, it seems, had a lot of fake news well before social media.
因为海地似乎早在社交媒体出现之前就有很多假新闻。
It was a country of rumor in some ways.
从某些方面来说,这是一个充满谣言的国家。
Or not?
或不?
I think you’re thinking of this whole thing of maybe that expression, Teledjòl, which is “the mouth that would go,” I guess it would be like.
我想你可能正在考虑这个表达,Teledjòl,它是“会走的嘴”,我想它会是这样的。
That was a way that information is spread.
这是信息传播的一种方式。
I don’t know.
我不知道。
I think every culture has that kind of rumor mill, if you will.
如果你愿意的话,我认为每种文化都有这种谣言工厂。
I don’t think that would be unique to Haitians.
我不认为这对海地人来说是独一无二的。
I think what I recognize in the whole fake news debate is the gradual slide towards autocracy.
我认为我在整个假新闻辩论中认识到的是逐渐滑向独裁。
Certainly, those of us who have lived through dictatorship and other moments like that, you recognize the slippery slope, the demonization of media, that sort of forced silencing.
当然,我们这些经历过独裁和其他类似时刻的人,你会认识到滑坡、媒体妖魔化和那种强迫沉默。
This summer I was reading with my girls.
今年夏天,我和女儿们一起读书。
We were reading Animal Farm, and it was really striking, all the parallels in terms of “What your eyes are seeing, you’re not seeing.” All that is very familiar in terms of that whole thing of diminishing the press.
我们正在读《动物农场》,这确实令人震惊,所有的相似之处都在于“你的眼睛看到的,你没有看到的”。就削弱新闻界而言,所有这些都是非常熟悉的。
Of course, at full autocracy, then you destroy the people who are giving the news.
当然,在完全独裁的情况下,你就会消灭那些发布消息的人。
But there are ways, now, with the social media, to do it.
但现在,通过社交媒体,有一些方法可以做到这一点。
Why do you think Haitian political history has shown so much instability in terms of turnover in the number of rulers?
您认为海地政治历史为何在统治者人数更替方面表现出如此大的不稳定?
We started as a country with everything against us right there.
我们一开始是一个一切对我们不利的国家。
Haitian Revolution was an impossibility to so many people.
海地革命对很多人来说是不可能的。
These enslaved people fought the French, the British, the Spanish, to start the first Black republic, the first place in the world, really, where enslaved people overcame their masters and started this nation in a world where slavery was the norm.
这些被奴役的人民与法国、英国、西班牙作战,建立了第一个黑人共和国,这是世界上第一个被奴役的人民战胜了他们的主人,并在奴隶制成为常态的世界中建立了这个国家的地方。
So Haiti was shunned, and we had to pay to the French for this independence until into the next century.
因此,海地被避开了,我们不得不向法国人支付独立费用,直到下个世纪。
I think there was so much stacked up against us, and then, in the early 1900s, you had the very long US occupation, and then the dictatorship.
我认为有太多的因素对我们不利,然后,在 1900 年代初,美国长期占领,然后是独裁统治。
I think we were set up, in a way, to fail because this was not meant to exist.
我认为,在某种程度上,我们注定要失败,因为这本来就不应该存在。
Enslaved people starting their own country was not meant to exist.
被奴役的人建立自己的国家本来就不存在。
A lot of people have said it, and historians have said it, like, “How dare you?” I think to this day Haiti’s being told, “How dare you?”
很多人都这么说过,历史学家也这么说过,比如“你怎么敢?”我想直到今天,海地仍被告知:“你怎么敢?”
Many instances when we’ve elected our leaders, then suddenly there’s a coup or there’s .
很多情况下,当我们选出领导人后,突然发生政变或发生政变。
.
。
.
。
So I think the instability is not fully the fault of Haitians.
所以我认为不稳定并不完全是海地人的错。
We’ve had our part where people have decided to turn against their own, but it’s also something that has been set up to fail.
我们已经经历了人们决定反对自己的部分,但这也是注定要失败的事情。
What did the United States get most wrong in its 1915 to 1934 occupation of Haiti?
美国在1915年至1934年占领海地期间犯下的最大错误是什么?
Being there?
在那里?
COWEN: Sure, but there’s better and worse occupations, right?
COWEN:当然,但是职业也有好坏之分,对吧?
Oh, I don’t think the people who have been occupied anywhere would ever say, “What a great occupation!”
哦,我不认为那些在任何地方被占领过的人会说:“多么伟大的占领啊!”
Well, say Barbados may have gone better than, say, some other countries in the Caribbean — it’s occupation.
好吧,巴巴多斯可能比加勒比地区的其他一些国家表现得更好——这是占领。
I think you mean Grenada or —
我想你指的是格林纳达或者 ——
Grenada also.
格林纳达也。
They went better than Suriname.
他们比苏里南表现更好。
The Dutch were more extractive in Suriname than the British were in Barbados.
荷兰人在苏里南的榨取程度比英国人在巴巴多斯的榨取程度还要高。
I would ask them.
我会问他们。
I don’t know.
我不知道。
I would not speak for them.
我不会为他们说话。
I think people always want to be in charge of their fate.
我认为人们总是想掌控自己的命运。
And the people who come, often, from what I know of the US occupation .
据我所知,这些人通常来自美国占领时期。
.
。
.
。
and the writers at that time wrote about it.
当时的作家们写下了这件事。
There were African Americans scholars who were living the moment, who visited, who wrote about it because it was meant for influence in the region.
有一些非裔美国学者生活在当下,他们来访,他们写下它,因为它是为了在该地区产生影响。
One of the heads — I think it’s Butler, his name was — who had a mea culpa many years later, who was in charge of not just the occupation of Haiti, but also at that time, when there was a common occupation of Haiti and the DR where he said, “We were there for City Bank.
其中一位负责人 —— 我想是巴特勒,他的名字是 —— 多年后他感到愧疚,他不仅负责占领海地,而且负责当时对海地和民主共和国的共同占领,他说:“我们是为了城市银行。
We were there for money.” That was his mea culpa.
我们是为了钱才去那里的。”这是他的过失。
There’s the example of — you’ve talked about Haitian art — Philomé Obin, who’s a Haitian artist from the north, has a very famous painting about Charlemagne Péralte, who was a leader of the Cacos, who fought against the occupation, who was murdered and attached to a door as a kind of frightening.
有这样一个例子:“你谈到了海地艺术”——菲洛姆·奥宾(Philomé Obin)是一位来自北方的海地艺术家,他有一幅非常著名的关于查理曼·佩拉尔特(Charlemagne Péralte)的画作,他是卡科斯(Cacos)领袖,反抗占领,被谋杀并被挂在门上以示恐惧。
And there were some horror stories, some massacres during the occupation.
占领期间发生了一些恐怖故事和屠杀。
What was left behind after the occupation, both in Haiti and the Dominican Republic, was this military structure that went through the generations.
海地和多米尼加共和国被占领后留下的是这种代代相传的军事结构。
In the Dominican Republic side, it became Trujillo, who then carried out this 1937 massacre of Haitians.
在多米尼加共和国方面,则是特鲁希略,他随后实施了1937年对海地人的屠杀。
Then on our side, it went all the way down through the army that ended up in that dictatorship.
然后在我们这边,它一直通过军队,最终进入了独裁统治。
There was also a deeper layering of basically moving Jim Crow to these islands because, for the comfort of these people, they had to create these clubs to separate people who are light versus people who are dark in terms of how they interacted with them.
还有一个更深层次的问题,基本上是将吉姆·克劳(Jim Crow)转移到这些岛屿上,因为为了这些人的舒适,他们必须创建这些俱乐部,以在与他们互动的方式上区分光明的人和黑暗的人。
So it’s not fun.
所以这并不好玩。
In retrospect, do you think the US restoration of Aristide in 1994 was a mistake?
现在回想起来,您认为美国1994年恢复阿里斯蒂德是一个错误吗?
Was it more colonialism?
是不是更加殖民主义?
Or was it the best thing that somehow had to be done?
或者这是必须以某种方式完成的最好的事情?
I think that was a very difficult moment, and those generals in that moment .
我认为那是一个非常困难的时刻,而那些将军们在那一刻。
.
。
.
。
During that coup d’état, thousands and thousands of people had been killed.
在那次政变中,成千上万的人被杀害。
At that time, I was working on a film called Tonbe leve, and we were interviewing many people who had been victimized during the coup d’état.
当时,我正在拍一部叫《Tonbe Leve》的电影,我们采访了许多在政变中受害的人。
One of them was an incredibly brave woman named Anette Bellance who had survived and been really butchered and had lost her arm, and other people.
其中一位是一位非常勇敢的女性,名叫安妮特·贝兰斯(Anette Bellance),她幸存下来,并被真正屠杀,失去了手臂和其他人。
I think at that time, President Aristide was part of that decision, and he wanted to return.
我想当时阿里斯蒂德总统也是这个决定的一部分,他想回来。
At that time, I guess, that was the right thing to do.
当时我想,这是正确的做法。
The generals — they were ready to stay, and people were dying.
将军们——他们准备留下来,而人们正在死去。
That was the decision that was made by President Aristide, and he returned.
这是阿里斯蒂德总统做出的决定,他回来了。
If you were minister of education in Haiti and had a fair amount of latitude, what would you do?
如果你是海地的教育部长并且拥有相当大的自由度,你会做什么?
I would give the job to a woman I know who runs an organization called Anseye pou Ayiti, and her name is Nedgine .
我会把这份工作交给一位我认识的女士,她经营着一个名为 Anseye pou Ayiti 的组织,她的名字叫 Nedgine。
Nedgine works with schools.
Nedgine 与学校合作。
Actually, she works with educators.
事实上,她与教育工作者一起工作。
If I were minister, first of all, I would make sure people who are better qualified than me were minister of education.
如果我是部长,首先我会确保比我更有资格的人担任教育部长。
But one thing I think would be important, to actually make sure every single child is educated and to make sure that Creole is part of the education because often, children just jump into school in French, and there’s a lot of rote memorization.
但我认为有一件事很重要,那就是要真正确保每个孩子都受到教育,并确保克里奥尔语成为教育的一部分,因为通常孩子们只是用法语进入学校,并且有很多死记硬背。
That would be an important thing, I think, to make sure every child has access to education because in Haiti, something like 40 percent of a parent’s income is spent on education.
我认为,这对于确保每个孩子都能接受教育是一件很重要的事情,因为在海地,家长收入的 40% 左右都花在了教育上。
And often, the children are not getting the best education because it’s rote memorization.
通常,孩子们得不到最好的教育,因为这是死记硬背。
What I know is, there’s such a love for education in Haiti that parents really, really sacrifice a great deal to have their children educated, that every child, of course, deserves an education.
我所知道的是,海地人非常热爱教育,父母为了让孩子接受教育确实付出了巨大的牺牲,当然,每个孩子都应该接受教育。
I would love for every child to have that opportunity.
我希望每个孩子都有这样的机会。
I think that would be the most important thing to have, a good education that could serve them and help them to function and grow in their country.
我认为这是最重要的事情,良好的教育可以为他们服务并帮助他们在自己的国家发挥作用和成长。
As a Haitian American, how do you feel your perspective on Black Lives Matter might be different from that of many Black Americans?
作为一名海地美国人,您认为您对“黑人生命也是命”的看法可能与许多美国黑人不同?
It’s not different.
这没什么不同。
I believe that Black lives matter, of course.
当然,我相信黑人的生命很重要。
I think, maybe, as a Haitian American with the history that I’ve just outlined to you, with having come out of a culture of revolution and the constant fight that Haitians have always had, we can certainly identify with that.
我想,也许,作为一名海地美国人,有着我刚才向你们概述的历史,来自海地人一直以来的革命文化和持续不断的斗争,我们当然可以认同这一点。
Absolutely.
绝对地。
One thing that’s been really wonderful to see with this generation is that, as Black immigrants, there’s no separation.
对于这一代人来说,一件非常美妙的事情是,作为黑人移民,没有分离。
Maybe in previous generations, there was that feeling that “Oh, this is not my problem.” But in the demonstrations, you see Haitian flags.
也许在前几代人中,有一种“哦,这不是我的问题”的感觉。但在示威活动中,你会看到海地国旗。
You see Dominican flags.
你看到多米尼加国旗。
You see people from the continent.
你看到来自非洲大陆的人。
I think we realize that this affects all of us.
我认为我们意识到这会影响我们所有人。
It’s my nephews.
这是我的侄子们。
It’s my African American friends that I grew up with, their children, my children.
和我一起长大的是我的非裔美国朋友,他们的孩子,我的孩子。
It’s certainly a common struggle.
这当然是一场共同的斗争。
Certainly, that cop is not going to be asking you which country you’re from when doing these types of encounters.
当然,在进行此类遭遇时,警察不会问你来自哪个国家。
Now, in all of these conversations, there’s a segment where I present to the guest my favorite Haitian proverbs, and he or she reacts.
现在,在所有这些对话中,有一个片段是我向客人展示我最喜欢的海地谚语,然后他或她做出反应。
Are you ready for a few?
你准备好几个了吗?
All right.
好的。
You’ve been sharing Haitian proverbs with your guests?
您一直在与客人分享海地谚语吗?
Here’s one.
这是一个。
“After the dance, the drum is heavy.”
“舞毕,鼓声重。”
Oh my god.
我的天啊。
What does that mean to you?
这对你来说意味着什么?
Aprè dans, tanbou lou.
Aprè dans, tanbou lou。
I actually have a book called After the Dance.
我实际上有一本书叫《舞后》。
It’s on Carnival.
这是在嘉年华上。
Yes, for me, it means that there are consequences to everything, even the most joyful thing.
是的,对我来说,这意味着一切都会有后果,即使是最快乐的事情。
You have to be prepared for the consequences of things that you’ve done.
你必须为你所做的事情的后果做好准备。
It’s something that my mom used to say quite a bit, too.
这也是我妈妈经常说的话。
If you have just had a really big celebration, or if you waited too late to do your homework because you’re having a good time watching a program you like, she was like, “Aprè dans, tanbou lou.” After the dance, the drum is heavy.
如果你刚刚举行了一场非常盛大的庆祝活动,或者你因为看自己喜欢的节目而玩得很开心而太晚才做作业,她就会说,“Aprè dans, tanbou lou。”舞毕,鼓声重重。
It’s like the morning-after, hangover situation and the most joyful outcome, but really, that there are consequences to everything.
这就像宿醉后的早晨和最令人高兴的结果,但实际上,一切都会有后果。
Here’s another one.
这是另一个。
“It is the owner of the body who looks out for the body.”
“照顾这具尸体的是这具尸体的主人。”
Oh, this one.
哦,这个。
You will not believe how much we hear that these days.
你不会相信这些天我们听到了多少这样的说法。
Se mèt kò ki veye kò.
Se mèt kò ki veye kò。
It’s something that we say a lot now in the coronavirus era.
这是我们在冠状病毒时代经常说的话。
You hear it on the radio.
你在收音机里听到的。
You hear people say it when they talk to their neighbors.
当人们与邻居交谈时,你会听到人们这么说。
Se mèt kò ki veye kò.
Se mèt kò ki veye kò。
That means that, really, you are the best person to take care of yourself.
这意味着,实际上,您是照顾自己的最佳人选。
If you’re saying, “Wear your mask when you go out during the coronavirus era.” “Wash your hands.” It’s like the best, the most qualified person to take care of you is you.
如果你说,“在冠状病毒时期外出时戴上口罩。” “洗手。”就好像最好、最有资格照顾你的人就是你自己。
It’s not the doctor.
这不是医生。
It’s not your loved one.
这不是你所爱的人。
Se mèt kò ki veye kò.
Se mèt kò ki veye kò。
It’s the owner of the body who takes care of the body.
身体的主人就是照顾身体的人。
It’s like, “Watch out for yourself.” It’s very good advice these days.
就像“当心你自己”。这些天这是非常好的建议。
“When they want to kill a dog, they say it’s crazy.”
“当他们想杀一只狗时,他们会说这太疯狂了。”
Yes, that’s the dehumanization.
是的,这就是非人化。
I guess that’s fake news.
我想那是假新闻。
It’s connected to the fake news.
这与假新闻有关。
If you want to diminish or slight someone, you call them names.
如果你想贬低或轻视某人,你就会辱骂他们。
So that’s also a timely one, I think.
所以我认为这也是及时的。
How about this one?
这个怎么样?
“The constitution is paper; the bayonet is steel.”
“宪法是纸,刺刀是钢。”
Yes.
是的。
Again, back to our conversation about dictatorship, in a way.
在某种程度上,再次回到我们关于独裁统治的对话。
I believe that one was often cited by one of the generals, actually, during the ’90s, during the coup d’état, or it might have been even before.
我相信,一位将军经常引用这句话,实际上,在 90 年代、政变期间,甚至可能更早。
I think it speaks to the fragility of documents like the constitution.
我认为这说明了宪法等文件的脆弱性。
Yesterday was Constitution Day in the US, so that might also apply here.
昨天是美国的宪法日,所以这也适用于这里。
It’s that whole thing with freedom.
这就是自由的全部。
Freedom is something that we have to always keep watching out it doesn’t slip away because, sometimes, we think these documents or these rules are set in stone.
自由是我们必须时刻注意的东西,不要让它溜走,因为有时,我们认为这些文件或这些规则是一成不变的。
I think this general who kept saying this was saying, “Well, I have the weapons.” It’s kind of paper, rock scissors.
我认为这位一直说这句话的将军是在说:“好吧,我有武器。”这是一种石头剪刀布。
Which is stronger?
哪个更强?
“When the mapou tree dies, goats would eat its leaves.”
“当麻普树死后,山羊就会吃它的叶子。”
Yes.
是的。
This one, I think, is about humility because we have this expression that we say when someone has died who has contributed a great deal to our culture: we say that a mapou has fallen.
我认为,这与谦卑有关,因为当有人为我们的文化做出了巨大贡献的人去世时,我们会说这样的表达方式:我们说“mapou已经倒下”。
A mapou is a soft cotton tree, it’s a kind of sacred tree, and it’s also a big tree that lasts forever.
麻普树是一种柔软的棉树,它是一种神树,也是一棵长生不老的大树。
It’s a regal institution, a mapou.
这是一个皇家机构,一个mapou。
What this one is saying, actually, the goat is a meager creature compared to a mapou, and there’s no way a goat would actually be able to access the leaves of a mapou, but when it dies, it falls.
实际上,与马普相比,山羊是一种微不足道的生物,山羊实际上不可能接触到马普的叶子,但当它死时,它就会掉落。
I’ve always heard that proverb as a way of encouraging humility, that all our leaves are vulnerable to the goat, if you will.
我一直听说这句谚语是鼓励谦逊的一种方式,如果你愿意的话,我们所有的叶子都容易受到山羊的攻击。
COWEN: One more proverb, “Beyond the mountain is another mountain.”
考恩:还有一句谚语,“山的另一边是另一座山。”
Yes.
是的。
Dèyè mòn gen mòn.
Dèyè mòn gen mòn。
That’s a very famous one.
这是一位非常有名的人。
Yes.
是的。
I actually use that a lot myself.
我自己实际上也经常使用它。
One of my neighbors just passed away, and she used to use that proverb a lot.
我的一位邻居刚刚去世,她经常使用这句谚语。
I think it means that no matter what, we can see there is more.
我认为这意味着无论如何,我们都能看到更多。
I think it’s about there’s more to everything than what we see.
我认为一切都比我们所看到的更多。
It also speaks to the physical layout of Haiti because it’s a very mountainous place.
它还说明了海地的物理布局,因为它是一个多山的地方。
Ayiti.
阿依提。
The Arawak called it Ayiti.
阿拉瓦克人称其为Ayiti。
It actually means land of the mountains, and it’s physically true.
它实际上意味着山地,而且在物理上也是如此。
If you’re traveling across Haiti, literally, there’s always a mountain physically behind a mountain, but in a spiritual sense, it also means that there’s always more.
如果你在海地旅行,从字面上看,山后面总是有一座山,但从精神意义上来说,这也意味着总是有更多的山。
There’s this mountain-connected saying that I love, which says “de mòn pa janm kontre, men nou menm petèt yon jou nou ka kontre,” which means — and it’s a great closer in a way — it means two mountains can never meet but perhaps, you and I, we can meet again.
我很喜欢这句与山有关的谚语,它说“de mòn pa janm kontre, men nou menm petèt yon jou nou ka kontre”,意思是 —— 在某种程度上,这是一个伟大的接近 —— 这意味着两座山永远无法相遇,但也许,你和我,我们可以再次相遇。
Have you ever been to West Africa?
你去过西非吗?
I have not.
我没有。
I have only been to South Africa.
我只去过南非。
Actually, this year, we were hoping to make a trip to different countries in Africa, but we’re obviously not able to.
其实今年我们本来希望能去非洲不同的国家旅行,但显然没能成行。
I’m 51 now.
我现在51岁了。
I feel like I should have already made it, but it’s definitely something that I’ve wanted to do with my family, with my girls, and that hopefully we’ll all get to do together.
我觉得我应该已经做到了,但这绝对是我想和我的家人、我的女儿们一起做的事情,希望我们都能一起做。
What is special about Jacmel in Haiti?
海地雅克梅勒有什么特别之处?
Jacmel.
雅克梅勒.
One thing — there’s a wonderful novel by a great Haitian writer, René Depestre, called Hadriana in All My Dreams, which was recently translated by Kaiama Glover.
有一件事——海地伟大作家雷内·德佩斯特有一本精彩的小说,名叫《我所有的梦想中的哈德里亚娜》,最近由凯阿马·格洛弗翻译。
That novel will tell you everything you want to know about Jacmel.
那本小说将告诉你关于雅克梅勒你想知道的一切。
It’s a beautiful place, and the location — it’s got both the mountains and the sea.
这是一个美丽的地方,而且地理位置 ——有山有海。
It’s got a wonderful waterfall called Bassin Bleu.
它有一个美丽的瀑布,叫做 Bassin Bleu。
It’s a gorgeous place.
这是一个美丽的地方。
After the Dance, the book that I wrote — it’s about Carnival and Jacmel.
《舞会之后》,我写的书——是关于嘉年华和雅克梅勒的。
It has a spectacular Carnival as well.
这里还有盛大的狂欢节。
There are some wonderful artists who live there, actually, who I write about in After the Dance — one of them, Ronald Mevs, who still lives there next to a beautiful mountain.
事实上,有一些出色的艺术家住在那里,我在《舞后》中写到了他们——其中之一,罗纳德·梅夫斯,他仍然住在一座美丽的山旁边。
Now, in your own life, how did you manage to be such a prodigy?
那么,在你自己的生活中,你是如何成为这样的神童的呢?
You come to the US.
你来美国。
You’re 12.
你12岁了。
You grew up speaking Creole.
你是说克里奥尔语长大的。
By the time you’re 14, you’re writing for something called New Youth Connections perfectly fluently.
当你 14 岁的时候,你已经可以非常流利地为《New Youth Connections》撰写文章了。
Then, your first book is published as an undergraduate.
然后,你的第一本书作为本科生出版。
What accounts for this?
这是什么原因造成的?
What’s your own story about the beginnings of your own success?
关于您自己的成功的开始,您有什么故事吗?
Well, my first book actually was published when I was 24.
嗯,我的第一本书实际上是在我 24 岁时出版的。
That’s still early, but I loved writing.
虽然还为时过早,但我喜欢写作。
I loved stories, and I loved writing.
我喜欢故事,也喜欢写作。
For me, it was always fun, even when I was doing other things.
对我来说,这总是很有趣,即使我在做其他事情时也是如此。
I was studying at school, but I loved to write.
我在学校读书,但我喜欢写作。
You know that saying that people say, “If you love what you do, you’ve never worked a day in your life.” For me, really, I wanted to write, and it started with New Youth Connections, that journal that I started writing for when I was 14, and went through all my books to this day.
你知道人们常说的一句话:“如果你热爱你所做的事,那么你一生中就没有工作过一天。”对我来说,真的,我想写作,从《New Youth Connections》开始,我从 14 岁开始为这本杂志写作,直到今天我还浏览了我所有的书。
I knew that my book was published early, and a lot was made of that, I think, as when you publish when you’re young, but for me, it was just always a joy.
我知道我的书很早就出版了,我想,就像你年轻时出版的那样,这里面有很多内容,但对我来说,这总是一种快乐。
It was just something I love doing, and I always felt really blessed to be able to do it, and I still feel that way to today.
这只是我喜欢做的事情,能够做到这一点我总是感到非常幸运,直到今天我仍然有这种感觉。
What’s your most productive or most unusual work habit?
您最高效或最不寻常的工作习惯是什么?
Working at night, and the older I’m getting, the harder it is to actually stay up all night, but I find that writing at night is really my most productive time because somehow, at night, you just feel everybody is safe in bed that I’m responsible for, and there’s not too many distractions.
在晚上工作,随着年龄的增长,真正熬夜就越困难,但我发现晚上写作确实是我最有生产力的时间,因为不知何故,在晚上,你会觉得每个人都安全地躺在床上,这是我负责的,而且没有太多干扰。
The internet is always there, but it’s just easier to imagine a whole other universe at night.
互联网始终存在,但更容易想象晚上的另一个宇宙。
I feel that that’s when I’m most productive.
我觉得那是我最有生产力的时候。
Being a Haitian American writer, what criticisms do you feel you get from Haitians?
作为一名海地裔美国作家,您认为海地人对您提出了哪些批评?
Is there any tension there?
那里有紧张吗?
I think there’s always tensions but not so much because of the people who read me.
我认为紧张总是存在的,但并不是因为读我文章的人。
I have friends from other groups.
我有其他团体的朋友。
It’s the same.
是一样的。
You seem to be plucked out of your group, and people think you consider yourself a representative.
你似乎被从你的群体中剔除出来,人们认为你认为自己是代表。
I’ve never considered myself a representative for Haitians, all Haitians.
我从来不认为自己是海地人的代表,所有海地人的代表。
I don’t think I speak for all Haitians.
我不认为我代表所有海地人。
But often, when you’re spoken about in the press, people put you as a kind of sociologist, as a kind of expert on Haiti.
但通常,当媒体谈论你时,人们将你视为社会学家、海地问题专家。
When I started pretty young, “I just want to tell this story.
当我很小的时候就开始了,“我只是想讲这个故事。
I want to tell that story.” Then, I started to realize that people were, at times, overgeneralizing my stories.
我想讲这个故事。”然后,我开始意识到人们有时会过度概括我的故事。
They would say, “Oh, this character in your book does that, and that’s what all Haitians do.”
他们会说,“哦,你书中的这个角色就是这样做的,这就是所有海地人所做的。”
Of course, some of my compatriots didn’t like that because people would literally say to me, “Oh, that person read your book and said that.
当然,我的一些同胞不喜欢这样,因为人们实际上会对我说:“哦,那个人读了你的书并这么说。
They think that’s my life, too.” That happens, I think, with the work of writers of color a lot.
他们也认为这就是我的生活。”我认为这种情况在有色人种作家的作品中经常发生。
For example, Alice Walker — people say, “Oh, because she writes this character, then she hates Black men.”
例如,爱丽丝·沃克(Alice Walker)——人们说,“哦,因为她写了这个角色,所以她讨厌黑人。”
For me, they were saying, “Oh, because you wrote about this girl whose family really wanted her to be a virgin, that means everybody who’s Haitian has the same situation.” I think that people in the mainstream culture sometimes generalize what we write.
对我来说,他们说,“哦,因为你写了这个女孩,她的家人真的希望她成为处女,这意味着每个海地人都有同样的情况。”我认为主流文化中的人们有时会概括我们所写的内容。
That leads to some tensions within the culture.
这导致了文化内部的一些紧张局势。
I’ve had some rebuke, which is normal.
我受到过一些责备,这很正常。
Again, there are circumstances to whatever you write, whatever you do.
再说一遍,无论你写什么,无论你做什么,都有环境。
I learned from that.
我从中吸取了教训。
I started out very young, so I think over the years, I’ve also had to learn how to tell maybe more nuanced stories and how to be conscious of just how what I write will be read by different types of people.
我从很小的时候就开始了,所以我想多年来,我还必须学习如何讲述更微妙的故事,以及如何意识到我写的东西将如何被不同类型的人阅读。
You’ve taught a history of Haitian cinema class at Ramapo College.
您在拉马波学院教授海地电影史课程。
Correct?
正确的?
What did you do in that?
你在其中做了什么?
Well, actually, we taught that class when — it was Jonathan Demme and Haitian journalist Jean Dominique — when Jean was in exile from Haiti.
嗯,实际上,我们在 Jonathan Demme 和海地记者 Jean Dominique 的时候教过这门课,当时 Jean 从海地流亡。
Jonathan wanted to do, actually, a festival of Haitian cinema.
事实上,乔纳森想要举办一个海地电影节。
We used that class as a way of, first of all, finding the films that we would show, and then to talk about them.
我们利用这堂课首先找到我们要放映的电影,然后讨论它们。
There’s a Haitian film, for example, called Anita, which is about a young girl who’s a domestic servant in a home.
例如,有一部海地电影《安妮塔》,讲述了一个年轻女孩在家里当佣人的故事。
Haitian singer TiCorn is featured in it.
海地歌手 TiCorn 是其中的主角。
We would get that film.
我们会得到那部电影。
We would show it, and we’d talk about it.
我们会展示它,我们会讨论它。
Jean, who was more versed in Haitian cinema than either of us, would speak on it, and then the students would film it.
吉恩比我们更精通海地电影,他会谈论它,然后学生们将其拍摄下来。
I hope all of this is in the archives at Ramapo College.
我希望所有这些都在拉马波学院的档案中。
It was both a history of cinema class, but also a class in which the students got an opportunity to film what we were doing.
这既是一堂电影历史课,也是一堂让学生有机会拍摄我们正在做的事情的课。
We were trying to figure what had been done in Haitian cinema before.
我们试图弄清楚海地电影以前做过什么。
Soon after that — not because of us — but there was a kind of explosion of Haitian cinema.
不久之后——“不是因为我们”——而是海地电影出现了爆炸式增长。
There were a lot of films made — some of them wonderful, some not so great — but there were a couple of keepers.
拍了很多电影——“有些很棒,有些不太好”——但有几个守护者。
If we were doing this project now, for example, we would have a lot more to work with, with the films of Raoul Peck and other filmmakers inside Haiti.
例如,如果我们现在做这个项目,我们将有更多的工作要做,包括拉乌尔·佩克和海地境内其他电影制片人的电影。
Two final questions.
最后两个问题。
First, let’s say our listeners are thinking of doing a trip to Haiti — which by the way, I would recommend strongly — but what tip would you give them for how they can make it somehow manageable and safe, assuming, of course, they’re not Haitian?
首先,假设我们的听众正在考虑去海地旅行 ——顺便说一句,我强烈推荐——但是你会给他们什么建议,让他们如何让旅行变得易于管理和安全,当然,假设他们不是海地人?
Well, a lot of people go to Haiti.
嗯,很多人都去海地。
I think you have to go with an open mind.
我认为你必须以开放的心态去。
I would say try to get out of Port-au-Prince, to go outside, go see the countryside.
我想说尝试离开太子港,到外面去,看看乡村。
For example, in the south, there’s some wonderful grottoes or caves.
例如,在南方,有一些奇妙的石窟或洞穴。
There are some hikes.
有一些徒步旅行。
Not to try to stay in the urban space but also to go outside.
不要试图留在城市空间,而是要走出去。
I think it’s Palmer’s Guide to both Haiti and the Dominican Republic that has some wonderful tips in terms of where to go.
我认为帕尔默的海地和多米尼加共和国指南在去哪里方面提供了一些精彩的建议。
There’re also some local traveling groups.
还有一些当地的旅行团。
If you’ve never been to Haiti, and you don’t know anybody in Haiti, try to find a group to accompany you.
如果您从未去过海地,并且在海地不认识任何人,请尝试找一个团体陪伴您。
But to go with an open mind, to try to learn and listen, and certainly, go outside the urban space into the countryside.
但要以开放的心态去尝试学习和倾听,当然还要走出城市空间进入乡村。
I would recommend.
我会推荐。
To close, finally, if you could give us one more Haitian proverb that is dear and important to you.
最后,请您再给我们讲一句对您来说很珍贵且重要的海地谚语。
Well, this one reminds me very much of Jonathan, who, though he was not Haitian, I probably traveled with him more to Haiti than my own parents when I worked for him.
嗯,这个让我很想起乔纳森,虽然他不是海地人,但当我为他工作时,我和他一起去海地的次数可能比我自己的父母还多。
He always used to say, “Piti piti, zwazo fè nich.” Little by little, the bird builds its nest.
他总是说:“Pitipiti,zwazofènich。”小鸟一点一点地筑起了它的巢。
That was his favorite answer to, like, if you asked him how he was doing, he would say, “Piti piti, zwazo fè nich.”
这是他最喜欢的回答,比如,如果你问他过得怎么样,他会说,“Piti piti, zwazo fè nich。”
Unfortunately, as you know, he passed away not too long ago.
不幸的是,如你所知,他不久前去世了。
That was one of his favorites.
这是他的最爱之一。
That remains very special to me for that reason, but also what the proverb says.
出于这个原因,这对我来说仍然非常特别,而且这也是谚语所说的。
It’s kind of like that — every journey begins with one step.
有点像这样 ——每一段旅程都从一步开始。
I feel like it’s good advice these days.
这些天我觉得这是个好建议。
Piti piti, zwazo fè nich.
皮蒂皮蒂,zwazo fè nich。
Little by little, the bird builds its nest.
小鸟一点一点地筑起了它的巢。
Edwidge Danticat, thank you very much.
艾德维奇·丹蒂卡特,非常感谢你。
It’s been a pleasure.
这是一种乐趣。
Thank you.
谢谢。
Thank you for having me.
谢谢你有我。
Photo credit: Carl Juste
照片来源:卡尔·贾斯特